CAD 3D Mechanical Interoperability WG CAD 3D Mechanical Interoperability WG
Last update: May 2019

The objective of the “CAD 3D Mechanical interoperability” working group is to ensure the coordination and the consistency of all standardisation activities related to “CAD 3D Mechanical” interoperability, including Product Manufacturing Information (PMI).

This working group is part of the ASD SSG “PLM interoperability” domain.

 

 

The recommendations of the working group cover product information interoperability for the full life cycle of the mechanical part development, from specifications to maintenance and dismantlement. It covers all the interoperability functions based on open standards, such as:

  • integration between heterogeneous authoring applications (upstream, downstream, ...)
  • communication with the extended enterprise or with the customers,
  • visualisation,
  • long term archiving and retrieval,
  • data quality,
  • and migration.

This web page will be regularly updated.

 

Scope

 The following picture describes a generic process of development of mechanical part.

Nota: Same figure than for the AIA – ASD Stan LOTAR “3D PMI” working group
 

List of use cases

The following table list the use cases to be supported by the international standards for 3D geometry and Mechanical information interoperability.
 

CAD 3D PMI "graphic"

 

CAD 3D PMI "graphic" exchange for visualisation

Draft

CAD 3D  PMI "graphic" Long Term Archiving &Retrieval  for certification

LOTAR

3D PMI Interface Control Model  (ICM) exchange

TBD

CAD 3D with PMI "semantic"

 

CAD 3D with PMI "semantic" exchange for down stream reuse

Draft

CAD 3D PMI "semantic" migration

Draft

CAD 3D PMI "semantic" Long Term Archiving &Retrieval  for manufacturing and repairs

Draft

CAD 3D tolerance stack up

TBD

CAD assemblies and 3D simplified

 

CAD assemblies and 3D simplified geometry with PMI models exchange for bid

TBD

CAD 3D exchange for DMU review/clash detection

Draft

CAD 3D PMI "parametric"

 

CAD 3D PMI "parametric" exchange for upstream reuse (CAD <=> CAE)

TBD

CAD 3D PMI "parametric" exchange for down stream reuse (CAD-CAM)

TBD

CAD 3D PMI "parametric" Long Term Archiving &Retrieval  (for reuse)

Draft

         (*) LOTAR stands for Term Archiving and retrieval

Nota: for access to use cases for Long Term Archiving and retrieval, refer to the LOTAR “3D CAD with PMI” WG web page:

 http://www.lotar-international.org/lotar-workgroups/3d-cad-with-pmi.html
 

ASD SSG 5 years vision

The 5 years vision of the ASD SSG “Mechanical interoperability” working group is set up on three principles:

 

1)      Mechanical interoperability ensured by the availability of business requirements, use cases, public test cases, ISO information model, recommended practices and interoperability test rounds of CAD vendors COTS standards interfaces.

 The operational use of Mechanical interoperability standards by the A&D industries requires the availability of:

  • Business requirements of the industry,
  • Use cases for Mechanical interoperability, supporting A&D business needs and priorities,
  • Public test cases for Mechanical interoperability, illustrating the use cases, 
  • International standards for Mechanical Information models (Cf. principle 2)
  • International and/or European recommended practices based on use cases, detailing the implementation of the ISO Mechanical information model,
  • Interoperability test rounds of the standardised Mechanical interfaces and services of the different PLM vendors, through the participation in the CAx Implementer Forum.

 

2)      Reliable ISO Information models for Mechanical interoperability.

 The ASD SSG recommends the choice of a limited number of core harmonised ISO 10303 Application Protocols, having interdependencies properly specified and managed through the time, completed by other relevant ISO 3D visualisation standards..

The ASD SSG recommends the use of ISO 10303 AP 242 edition 2 as the cornerstone standard for mechanical information interoperability (Ref. ASD SSG Feb. 2015 statement).

AP242 is developed in consistency with: 

  • STEP AP 238 edition 2 “Model based integrated manufacturing” - More information on www.ap238.org
  • STEP AP 209 edition 2 “Multidiciplinary Analysis and Design” - More information on www.ap209.org

 

Planned operational use of ISO standards for Mechanical interoperability and long term archiving:

 

Planned operational use

 

Short term 2019-2020

Midterm 2021-2022

Long Term +2023

Exchange - migration

STEP AP 242 ed1 (N1)

STEP AP 242 ed.2 (N4)

STEP AP 242 ed. 3

ISO 14306 (JT) ed.2 (N2)

ISO 14306 (JT) ed.2

ISO JT ed.3

LT Archiving and Retrieval

STEP AP 242 ed1 (N1)

STEP AP 242 ed.2 (N4)

STEP AP 242 ed. 3

Visualisation

STEP AP 242 ed1 (N1)

STEP AP 242 ed.2 (N4)

STEPAP 242 ed. 3

ISO 14306 (JT) ed.2 (N2)

ISO 14306 JT ed.2 

ISO 14306 JT ed.3

ISO PDF 3D: U3D/ISO PRC (N3)

 ISO PDF 3D: AP242 (N3) 

(N1) AP242 is the merge of AP214 and AP203

(N2) The following are outside the scope of this international standard (see related blip):

  • The definition orimplementation of a run-time architecture for viewing and/or processing JT data
  • Long-term data retention
  • Non-facted geometry data exchange.

(N3) U3D / ISO PRC: recommendation of the ASD SSG for these 3D visualization formats in progress.

(N4) ISO 10303 AP242 ed2 is planned to be published as an ISO standard end of 2019.

 
3)      Contribution to the development and use of the NAS / EN 9300 1xx family, for Long Term Archiving and Retrieval of Mechanical information.
The ASD SSG strategy relies on the joint AIA – ASD Stan LOTAR international project to develop the NAS / EN 9300-1XX standards for mechanical.
The LOTAR standards define Process, use cases, validation and verification rules for long term archiving and retrieval of mechanical information.  
 
Part
Title
Status
NAS / EN 9300-100
Common concepts for L-T Archiving and retrieval of CAD 3D mechanical information
Rel 2012
NAS / EN 9300-110
L-T Archiving and Retrieval of CAD 3D Explicit geometry information
Rel 2012
NAS / EN 9300-115
L-T Archiving and Retrieval of Explicit CAD assembly structure
Rel 2012
NAS / EN 9300-120e2
Long Term Archiving & Retrieval of CAD 3D Explicit Geometry with Graphic Product Manufacturing Information (PMI)
Rel 2018
NAS / EN 9300-121
Long Term Archiving & Retrieval of CAD 3D Explicit Geometry with PMI Semantic representation. 
Rel 2018
NAS / EN 9300-125
Long Term Archiving & Retrieval of Explicit CAD assembly structure with Graphic Product and Manufacturing Information (PMI)
Rel 2018
NAS / EN 9300-132
Long Term Archiving & Retrieval of 3D installation with holes and fasteners (N1)
2022?
 
 

Related standardization projects 
 

Standard/Specification

date

SSG blip

ISO 10303-203 edition 2 "Configuration controlled 3D design of mechanical parts and assemblies"

2011

 link

ISO 10303-214 edition 3 "Core data for automotive mechanical design processes"

2010

 link

ISO 10303-242 edition 1 "Managed Model-based 3D Engineering"

 2015

 link

ISO 10303-242 edition 2 "Managed Model-based 3D Engineering"

 2019

 link

ISO 14306 (JT) "file format specification for 3D visualization"

2018

 link

ISO 14739 "3D use of Product Representation Compact (PRC) format"

  

 

Related recommended practices